THE ROVING PECKER PRESENTS: "Have You Seen 'Everything?'" by Miz Cynical!
Greetings, Manor Hors! Periodically, "The Roving Pecker" presents urgent missives from
Since the movie "You Can See Everything" was released a few weeks ago, it has grossed almost $80 million at the box office. I’m shocked that it’s getting rave reviews from movie critics and viewers alike, generated Oscar buzz, gone viral and inspired a ton of memes and Halloween costumes. It’s Oscar season and there are a bunch of other movies that I feel are much more Oscar-worthy than this doc. I’ve seen a few outstanding movies recently and have a few more on my to-watch list that I’m willing to bet are far better.
I’m surprised by the response that this has received because I thought the majority of us were already familiar with Elizabeth Holmes’ story and had formed an opinion about her. Over the past ten years, her story has spawned books, podcasts and a Hulu series. Is there truly anything left for us to uncover? What more could we learn about her from a 3-hour long documentary? My opinion of Elizabeth Holmes is that she is a prime example of white woman privilege. And as a woman of color navigating through the United States, I’m unimpressed and not fascinated. It’s an all-too-familiar story I’ve seen before.
Every step of her career trajectory can be chalked up to the privilege of navigating this world looking the way she does and the socioeconomic structures in place that allowed her to get as far as she did. She played every card in the privileged white woman’s deck: from being able to secure financial backing for a dubious product that didn’t even have a proof of concept; to not facing any real scrutiny about her business operations; appointing a board that lacked board members that had medical backgrounds; blaming the brown guy (Ramesh “Sunny” Balwani); and then becoming pregnant as a last ditch effort to get a lighter prison sentence.
When I try to imagine attempting what Elizabeth did, but in my own skin - cosplaying Steve Jobs, adopting a deeper speaking voice and going before venture capitalists with my pitch being that I’m a college dropout and working on a revolutionary medical device - my fantasy doesn’t even come to a successful conclusion. Even though it’s just a fantasy, I envision that I’d be quickly escorted out of the building by security, assuming that I’d ever get an audience with those types of people to begin with. For me to imagine such a scenario is absurd, I can’t help but laugh. Being lauded for being a college dropout? Ha! Given millions of dollars for purposely cutting my access off to labs and medical expertise? Double-ha! Not to mention the fundamental medical education and training I would’ve undergone if I stayed in school? Stop, I’m crying from laughing so hard! Absurd for me to envision such a scenario, yet the same scenario wasn’t a joke for Elizabeth Holmes.
In addition to not being interested in Elizabeth Holmes, I’m also not a fan of Nathan Fielder. I suspect there’s a whiff of misogyny on Fielder’s part tied to his fascination with Holmes. Holmes managed to get away with ‘white collar’ crimes that are typically committed by white males. And from what I can gather, the most egregious of her crimes being the defrauding of investors.
We haven't heard nearly enough from her actual victims - people that were misdiagnosed or died due to her medical device that simply didn't work. But as one podcaster that I listen to put it, Holmes committed her crimes and is in jail. Currently, we have a slew of wealthy white males that are openly destroying our environment, committing fraud and other crimes every day right in plain sight. Where’s their documentary?
There’s no ‘gotcha’ moment in this doc. So, if Fielder isn’t revealing anything new about Holmes - we know that she’s mentally unhinged and lacks remorse - then what purpose does this movie serve? To exploit someone’s mental illness? If that’s the case, then this movie seems more exploitative than informative. At worst, I certainly don’t want to leave the theater feeling sympathetic to Holmes, a woman that we know is cunning enough to bully whistleblowers and journalists. At best, I don’t want to view Holmes as a kooky character, which would serve to lessen the severity of her crimes.
What say you, Peckers? Have you seen this movie? Do you plan on seeing it? If so, why or why not?
Photo Credit: A24


Comments
Post a Comment